Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Drip Specialty Coffee
Mocha Java Style
Colombia Supremo Swiss Water Decaf French Roast
Willoughby's Espresso Blend Decaf
About
Willoughby's Coffee & Tea
Welcome to Willoughby's Coffee & Tea, a hidden gem nestled in the vibrant heart of New Haven, Connecticut, at the bustling corner of 258 Church St. Renowned for its exceptional brews and welcoming atmosphere, this charming café invites coffee lovers and tea enthusiasts alike to indulge in a remarkable experience.
As you step inside, you are greeted by an abundance of natural light streaming through the large plate glass windows, creating a warm and inviting ambiance. Customers rave about the superb brewed drip coffee, praised as some of the best in New Haven. The coffee at Willoughby’s is roasted locally in Branford, ensuring ultimate freshness and an array of rich flavors that cater to all palates. From robust americanos to creamy lattes, each cup is crafted with precision and care, making your morning ritual feel truly special.
Beyond the coffee, Willoughby's also serves up a delightful selection of pastries that perfectly complement their beverages. Whether you are in the mood for a flaky croissant or a delectable muffin, you won’t be disappointed. Reviews from patrons like Ross Parish highlight the wonderful vibe and great pastries, making it an ideal spot to relax, sip, and savor.
For those looking to elevate their at-home coffee experience, Willoughby’s offers an impressive range of high-quality bagged beans. Cole von Richthofen shares his discovery of the coffee’s freshness, noting the delightful foam produced in his French press—a testament to the quality and attention to detail that Willoughby's embodies.
While the café lacks power outlets and a restroom, which some see as limitations, others lament they wouldn’t be able to leave such a delightful space if it had more amenities. This speaks volumes about the inviting culture cultivated at Willoughby's, where great service and fantastic coffee create a community feel. Regulars rave about the friendliness of the staff, ensuring that every visit feels personal and warm.
In a city brimming with coffee shops, Willoughby’s Coffee & Tea stands out not only for its remarkable coffee and pastries but also for its inviting atmosphere and commitment to quality. If you find yourself in New Haven, this is an experience you cannot miss. As the locals say, it's truly a coffee lover's paradise!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Best place for brewed drip coffee and bagged beans in NHV. Great vibe with tons of plate glass windows. Pastries are excellent too! The only limiting factor on me spending every day there is that they don't have power outlets or a bathroom. If they did, they'd need to have a way bigger space because they'd be too popular — I think they're onto something. ”
“ Solid place that sells a huge range of coffee bean roasted right here in aCT (Branford). The location and huge glass windows are outstanding ”
“ Quite literally some of the best coffee I have ever gotten. I recently tried Willoughby's for the first time, having grown sick of grocery store coffee. The ground coffee produced a lot of foam in my french press, meaning it's super fresh (I believe it's the release of CO2, but I am not certain). The flavor is amazing, great cup of coffee. If you are looking to make better coffee at home, do yourself a favor and get a bag of coffee from Willoughby's! ”
“ Fantastic experience. Great coffee. ”
“ Good Americanos. Very friendly service. ”
“ Coffee is an outstanding and strong. I have a Reminders of my college days in the coffee shop studying and drinking coffee. Nice staff and very professional knowledge of what people are wanting and listening with enthusiasm. ”
“ I ordered a mocha latte with oat milk and a toasted plain bagel. Both were excellent and a great start to the morning. This location is also taking some of the better covid precautions that i’ve seen. Hope to come back soon and try some other menu items. ”
“ Been going here for over three decades. It’s the best run establishment I’ve ever been to. The manager does a great job training her staff and it shows during your time there. The coffee is always great and the food is always fresh. ”